Cakes By Karen
About This Spot
Stepping into Cakes By Karen is like entering a quiet little haven where the soft hum of creativity blends effortlessly with the comforting promise of sweetness. Nestled in the heart of Aurora, this bakery feels more like a cherished neighborhood spot—intimate and unpretentious, yet brimming with a gentle excitement that hints at the care behind every creation. The pace here is unhurried, inviting visitors to slow down and savor not just the treats, but the thoughtfulness baked into each layered design.
The atmosphere is warm and patiently attentive, shaped by the genuine connection between the baker and those who come seeking something special. Whether it’s a whimsical unicorn-themed cake for a child’s joyful celebration or a carefully crafted wedding cake reflecting years of shared stories, the experience at Cakes By Karen goes far beyond frosting and fondant. It’s about capturing a moment—a quiet smile as a birthday cake is revealed, or the relief of finding a dessert that feels just right after a hectic week.
There’s a softness to the offerings here, in both flavor and form. Cakes turn out moist and thoughtfully balanced, often pairing classic favorites with unexpected touches—a whisper of custard, a hint of fresh fruit, or a creamy filling that holds its own without overwhelming. The magic isn’t just in the taste but in the way each cake seems tailored, personal, as if it were the result of a conversation rather than a mere order.
Those who know Cakes By Karen come back not only for the reliably excellent cakes but for the sense of calm and care that underpins the whole experience. It’s a place where creativity meets comfort, where every cake carries a quiet joy shared between baker and guest, making celebrations feel a little more heartfelt and a little more true.
What’s Available Here
-
Delivery
-
In-store pick-up
-
Takeaway
-
Dine-in
-
Wheelchair-accessible car park
-
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
-
Credit cards
-
Debit cards
-
Free parking lot
Location & Hours
| Monday | 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM | |
|---|---|---|
| Tuesday | 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM | |
| Wednesday | 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM | |
| Thursday | 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM | |
| Friday | 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM | |
| Saturday | 09:00 AM - 04:00 PM | |
| Sunday | Closed |
Emily R 07 Dec 2025
We ordered a Lego Ninjago cake and cookies for our son’s 3rd Birthday. The cake was marble with vanilla custard filling. Let me just say that was the best cake we’ve had in a long time! So moist, perfect vanilla and chocolate cake. The custard was perfectly not too sweet. Cookies were exactly as we thought they would be. Val was so nice and accommodating to what we wanted. We will always get our birthday cakes here!
Stephanie willis 29 Nov 2025
I order on 11/12 or 13th and the cake came out better than I imagined. She understood everything I wanted on my cake and made it happen! And the taste was incredible as well. This totally made up for a crappy cake I got from another bakery for last year. Will definitely be ordering my cakes from here from now on!
lexibug 23 Nov 2025
I've been going to Cakes by Karen for all of my special occasion cake needs for YEARS. I've purchased multiple cakes (The pictures shown are just what I have on my phone) and I've never been disappointed. Val is beyond amazing and has always made sure the cakes I ordered were to my specifications and even if I didn't have a clue what the specification was, Val always came through and made sure the details of the cake came out beautifully. Over the years, Cakes by Karen has become a wonderful part of my life and I'm so thankful for them. They've helped me celebrate birthdays, helped me through the passing of my mother and will be also have the honor of being my graduation cake when I graduate from college next year :) If you want a delicious cake (or cupcakes), excellent customer service and overall the best cakes in Aurora, Cakes by Karen is the place.
Cathryn Truebloood 15 Oct 2025
She was a lifesaver. So calm helped me make my daughter's birthday perfect. Even though I had almost no time from the date I ordered until I needed the cake. The quality of the cake was the best I have had in my 57 years. She decorated it Even better then I could have dreamed. I cannot recommend her enough.
Allyson Young 01 Oct 2025
Edit to Add: it’s been a couple years now since the Minion Cakes! I have ordered for almost every birthday. We ordered 3 cakes this year for birthdays. A Spider Man Cake, a Carrot Cake, and a Hello Kitty Cake! All were amazing!!! I won’t get cakes from anywhere else. Added More pictures of the recently ordered cakes! I just ordered my second cake from here! I was so impressed and happy with my Son’s First Birthday Cakes that I had to come back for my daughter’s birthday. If you’re thinking about it just do it! The cakes look amazing and the taste even better!
crystal padilla 27 Sep 2025
I've been getting cakes from here for about 8 years and they never fail me I am always excited to see what my cakes are going to look like in person even the one that we ordered over the phone was beyond what we could ever have imagined, the cake itself it so soft and flavorful. I will keep coming back and I come back for two reasons the first one is going to be the quality of the cake itself it's really good, and designs are also awesome but there is nothing better than walking into a bakery and seeing Val! She's amazing and super duper cool! and she's really knowledgeable in cupcakes and cakes she always makes sure I get exactly what you need and nothing more or nothing less. I will keep coming back to this location with my adult attitude because how can you be negative when you receive your cake from Cakes by Karen! so thank you Val and thank you Cakes by Karen for making our celebrations special!
Jessica Collins 24 Sep 2025
UPDATE: The cake was amazing, and beautiful, and DELICIOUS. We even had a lady from a different birthday party come over and take a picture of the cake. Absolutely, amazing cake! I will not actually pick up the cake for a couple months, but I just placed the order. The lady I talked to on the phone was very polite and helpful. She gave me options for the icing decorations and was very thorough. I am excited to see the cake come January!